So, here’s an interesting thing I learned in my new media adventure looking for all media related to Western New York: Tim Minear once produced a show that took place at Niagara Falls. And yes, I DO mean THAT Tim Minear. The very same Tim Minear who was buddied up with Joss Whedon to create Buffy the Vampire Slayer, one of the greatest shows of all time. The very same Tim Minear who again buddied up with Joss Whedon to create Firefly, probably the greatest CANCELLED show of all time. And what came of him this time was another gem of a television show… That got cancelled long before its time. Because it aired on Fox. Yes, that would be the very same Fox that famously aired Firefly completely out of sequence, shuffled around the starting time, and ultimately cancelled the show still having not ran four episodes. And that was more or less the same path taken by this show, Wonderfalls. Okay, it’s less. Firefly and Wonderfalls produced almost the same number of episodes. Firefly made four episodes which didn’t see the light until the DVD package. Wonderfalls made NINE. From a 13-episode series. Yes, you math whizzes, that means Fox only ever aired four episodes of Wonderfalls. Fox hates Tim Minear.
I should also mention that the two people credited with the proper creation of Wonderfalls are Bryan Fuller and Todd Holland. Holland is best known as a director. He’s done a few movies, but as his best-known movie was the 90-minute Super Mario Bros. 3 ad with Fred Savage known as The Wizard, it’s best not to talk about that. His acclaim comes from the episodes of The Larry Sanders Show and Malcolm in the Middle that he directed. Fuller’s resume is as infallible as Joss Whedon’s. Fuller is responsible for Dead Like Me, Pushing Daisies, Hannibal (which may take place in the same universe as Wonderfalls), American Gods, and Star Treks Deep Space Nine, Voyager, and Discovery. Judging from all these resumes, you may be able to venture a guess as to what kind of show Wonderfalls is: It’s a fantasy. It’s a very smart and creative fantasy too. It has memorable characters, creative plots, witty dialogue, and lots of stuffed animals who communicate with the main character. It also has some commendable Western New York connections: Yes, it takes place in Niagara Falls, New York, even though all the setup shots of the Falls are clearly from the Canadian side. (Face it, they wouldn’t look as good from the side of the Horseshoe, even from the Cave of the Winds.) Buffalo native William Sadler plays one of the main characters. Even the accent used by lead actress Caroline Dhavernas is a great approximation of a typical WNY accent, although she does lay it on a bit thick. (It’s harder than my own unapologetically thick WNY Lakes accent, which is really saying something.)
The show revolves around Jaye Tyler, a 24-year-old Brown University graduate who doesn’t give two shits about having graduated from an Ivy League school. She seems pretty content with what she’s currently doing with her life, which is working at a cheesy souvenir ship called Wonderfalls in Niagara Falls, New York. One thinks of Daria when it comes to Jaye, but Daria was capable of acting on her own conscience. Jaye needs to be pushed by plastic talking animals. Yeah, that’s the idea of Wonderfalls. One day at the store, Jaye gets into an argument with a customer who tried to make a wax lion, but the lion comes out wrong. Later, Jaye takes a hit and gets knocked out. When she comes to, the wax lion suddenly starts talking to her and telling her to do things. Jaye’s initial response is to ignore the lion and think she’s losing her mind, but eventually she gives in, and she sees the lives of people around her start to get better.
As Jaye goes, more inanimate animals start talking to her: Lawn flamingos, a McGruff-like cardboard cutout of a cartoon crime dog, and a Totem pole are just a few of the things that spring to life and give the confused Jaye orders. And they won’t stop giving her orders until she takes the time to go out and follow them! And unlike a lot of regular examples of this trope, Jaye doesn’t try to keep the weird talking animals to herself. In fact, she talks about them to her family and friends at will – and sometimes against THEIR will – but they just don’t believe her! Her brother thinks she’s turning into some kind of divine messenger, her best friend thinks she’s holding back and will talk about it when she’s ready, and the hot bartender she likes simply accepts it as part of her charm.
Yeah, the episodes of Wonderfalls don’t revolve around typical episodic television concepts. In one, Jaye and her brother chase their house maid into Canada and learn that she’s not a French immigrant, but a native of Canada. Another is about Jaye making friends with a shut-in at the trailer park she lives in. In another episode, Jaye turns a 13-year-old boy away from the mail-order bride he ordered… Only for him to turn his attention to her. Since this was done back in the days of 20-episode seasons, you can’t go into Wonderfalls expecting an overly long and complex serial arc, and that’s to its advantage. (It’s actually to the advantage of every show in the pre-streaming era, but I won’t start on that.) Wonderfalls doesn’t demand your overt attention at all times, and it feels no pressure to shock you every 10 minutes. All it asks is that you enjoy spending time with its quirks, characters, and oddball settings. The lighthearted and comedic tone doesn’t leave you completely drained to the point where you have to set it aside after every episode for a breather.
That’s not to say there aren’t any overall story arcs in the show. They exist, but they’re not there to carry the show on its back. That means that, despite its short number of episodes, the final episode – “Caged Bird” – was able to give one of the major story arcs an emotional conclusion satisfying enough to feel like a proper way to close the series itself. (More parallels to Firefly!) For a series that was cancelled after only 13 episodes, there’s a tight lot of character development packed into it – enough to leave you wanting to see more of it, and wondering what inventive directions the show would go in. Apparently there were already plans drawn up for the second and third seasons; the second would have developed an arc with Jaye and a therapist she started seeing, while a third season would have had Jaye checking into a mental hospital. Like Firefly, a lot of interesting plots can now never be answered; questions about how her friendship with Mahandra would go, how her brother Aaron’s views on these talking animals develop, about sister Sharon’s sexuality and ability to keep it a secret, and if she’ll ever open up to Eric. It really, really sucks that we’re never going to get conclusions here. But it’s all we have to cement Tim Minear’s reputation as the inventive showrunner who keeps making great, creative shows that networks are afraid of.